Read HC: John Marston w/ daughter!Reader from the story Red Dead Redemption: imagines & x reader's by kamadoes (NEZUKO) with 2,255 reads. Red Dead Wiki's article on her is simply titled "Marston Daughter". Hypothetical: what if Jack Marston isn't a Marston at all, because he isn't the son of John? The timeline of the game doesn’t make any sense anyway, John was apparently betrayed in 1906 yet he left the gang in 1899?? I find it strange that she wouldn't be mentioned, but I could believe that if she died young they would be more inclined to not bring it up and move on. John Marston's daughter? Unnamed female prostitute - Mother of John. Because no one reads these links, it says that a mission in RDR1 states that John's daughter died years after him leaving the gang. When she died is up in the air, but I would say she died or was miscarried/stillborn at least a few years before the first game because they probably would have mentioned her when they were reunited. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadmysteries community. A child can still be born and die between 1907 and 1911 I’ve said this countless times. GTA V released in 2013. It is a phenomenal game. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. One small thing I forgot to add. The Marston Family. Cuddling Headcanons - Transformers Prime an // first writing piece here, sorry if it sucks. Yep, you knew it was coming. Younger sister of Jack Marston. However the Epilogue of RDR2 takes place in 1907, and there is no sign of John’s daughter, Nor any mention of her in the epilogue at all. 2016? The following is my interpretation of what John's daughter would have been like. John and Abigail Marston had a daughter sometime between the events of Red Dead Redemption 2 and the original game, but unfortunately she died. After having dinner, John & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. First of all let’s look at the evidence. Just waiting in a cabinet until the story was told? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadredemption community. See more ideas about red dead redemption, red dead redemption ii, redemption. #jack marston #john marston #arthur morgan #rdr2 #red dead #red dead redemption #red dead redemption 2 #rdr #revenge #redemption #father and son #rdr2 jack #rdr2 video #rdr2 gif More you might like Finally got the new gaming pc! I feel like that would have been mentioned in an argument between them. The child was then born in 1900 or so, lived to 3-4, and then died in, say, 1904, so she's not around in 1907. This is actually a good theory too. Hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more! Blasphemy, right? Marston daughter is the deceased daughter of John Marston and his wife, Abigail, and Jack Marston’s younger sister. Mr. Marston - Father of John, of Scottish descent. The Red Dead Redemption series is one of the most tragic in all of gaming. Close. John Marston awakes one morning at his ranch to find that his daughter, who had died in 1906, is very much alive. arthur morgan Dutch Van Der Linde John Marston The idea for this came to me today and I had to quickly get this out of my system because I needed to see John yell that my art Too young to have experienced life, yet too old to go without the painful knowledge that her life would come to an early end. https://reddead.fandom.com/wiki/Marston_daughter. When Abagail Roberts first joined the gang she was a prostitute which means all the gang members had sex with her including: Dutch, Bill, Javier, Arthur, John … In red dead 1 John says he had a daughter you don’t know much about her what if she was born in red dead 2 when John left the gang cause Abigail and jack don’t talk about it and Javier seems to know about her, I thought she died between 1 and 2, there's a five year gap. spoiler. Micah Bell may be the villain of Red Dead Redemption 2, but judging from John Marston's actions in both the original Red Dead Redemption and its sequel, it appears John may not be much better than him.. Another added: “I think he is John’s and they fully intend Jack to be his kid regardless, but they throw these tidbits in there just to make people talk.” Press J to jump to the feed. Or who knows, maybe Abigail had fertility issues and miscarried before they had Jack and Javier (somehow) knew about it, but that's really unlikely. He probably wanted to live an honest life but not even 2 years in, he fucked it up and went back to Dutch because he at least had something to go back to. SPOLIER. So it's most likely they had her after settling in Beecher's when everything was nice and calm for once. Discussion. 2012? John Marston returns home to his ranch where he meets Abigail, Jack, & Uncle. 10. Those saddlebags are far larger than you think, boah. I tried working it out and it's a tad inconsistent. 11 months ago. I got a feeling it will be in the main story but maybe Rockstar forgot about her. What’s up with the fairly recent trend of leap years all being bad fucking years like 2008? John knows no fear because he had Arthur Morgan as his older brother. The undead plague descended upon the area of New Austin and playable hero John Marston was desperate to find a cure for his afflicted family. I always asssumed his year away was when he had a daughter hence leaving for a year. The Strange Man clearly isn't normal. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. She was four when she died. TLDR it's most likely she was born sometime after 1899 and died during or before 1907, but it's also possible she was born in 1907 or later and died before 1911. John Marston was born in 1873. I mean, people make "yo momma" jokes without knowing anything about the person's actual family, it's possible Javier was using a catch-all insult and didn't actually know whether or not Jack had any siblings. well there would be a grave then, i guess. It mixed Red Dead Redemption's open-world gameplay with a creepy and largely satirical story. Cookies help us deliver our Services. It may seem counter-intuitive to suggest that Micah and John Marston are both the same level of evil, especially since John is the main protagonist in the first Red Dead Redemption. Absolute fucking shit. It seems like they completely wrote that or merely forgot about it in the game, which is odd considering she was mentioned a few times by John and even once by Javier in RDR1. Archived. John Marston is the secondary protagonist of the 2010 video game Red Dead Redemption, The 2018 Video Game Red Dead Redemption 2 And the 2019 video game Red Dead Redemption 3. Most likely she died between the end of chapter six and the start of the epilogue, or the end of the epilogue and the start of the first game. This fits all of the scenarios without messing up the cannon. He served in the U.S. Army and National Guard from 1961-1964. Javier implies he assumes John's daughter is alive in RDR1 by referring to John's "children", which confirms that she didn't die before the gang's fall. Given how we don't see her in 1899, it's likely she lived and died either between the RDR2 story and the epilogue, or between the epilogue and RDR1. Therefore the most plausible scenario is that Abigail was pregnant during the final days of the gang and therefore Javier knew enough to say children. u/DBscamco. Though things were tense between John and Abigail at the start of the epilogue probably just because of being on the run and John shooting that guy. John Marston's daughter? She is briefly mentioned in the Bonnie MacFarlane mission "Women and Cattle", Nigel West Dickens mission "The Sport of Kings, and Liars", the Luisa Fortuna mission "Father Abraham", and indirectly in "The Gates of El Presidio" by Javier Escuella. She points out that Davey Callander had succumbed to his wounds. (Hi guys, just to let you know i'm new to Reddit, so bear with me!) I guess Javier just kept enough tabs on John go know he had a daughter, but likely lost interest in John after a while, or possibly she was had after the RDR2 epilogue when John was living under the radar at Beecher's Hope. Or Javier was just saying a general insult. While John Marston meets the Strange Man three times in his inaugural outing, the mustachioed, top-hat-wearing gentleman's true identity remains unknown. Posted by. John Marston Arthur morgan dutch van der linde Hosea matthews rdr2 thing is john probably forgot about what he did because Arthur didn't find it till weeks later look I did backgrounds half assed but they're there also all you who saw my mistake post can you … Edit: Jk, just saw this on his daughters wiki page “In the mission "Women and Cattle" John Marston mentions a gap of "years" between his time in the Van der Linde Gang and his daughter's death”. During Red Dead Redemption 1, It is mentioned that their was a Marston daughter who passed away before the first game took place, sometime between 1908-1910, It is stated that she was supposedly alive by 1906. After 8 long years we finally got to see the man behind the scars in a time where he wasn't as world-weary or as driven as we saw him in RDR1. Unnamed Marston daughter - Daughter of John and Abigail. Where would the daughter have been during the entire story? Uncle - Though Uncle is not related to the Marston family, he is treated as a family relative and friend. He knows what Marston is going to do before he does it, and he hints that Marston's tragic death is … Fucking shit. But since John lost all connection with the gang until Edgar Ross told him to hunt him down then how did Javier know about the daughter? Nothing is known about her, though dialogue in Red Dead Redemptionasserte… Shit. A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. This is purely speculation and more likely than not Rockstar didn't intend this, but I like to imagine that the death of the daughter is what compelled the Marstons to move back to the RDR2 map at the start of the epilogue. So i was really pleased to find out about John Marston's inclusion in RDR2 when he popped up in the 3rd trailer. John's father was blinded in both eyes during a bar fight south of Chicago at some stage, and loved to talk about Scotland and how he hated the English for what they did to his great-grandparents, although he never met them.In 1881, John's father passed away… Thanks to those who encouraged me today to keep posting this kind of thing <3. That’s a great point, they never say (as far as I know) that Abigail had John’s daughter. Players will meet younger versions of John and Abigail, Jack as a young boy, and even Uncle. requests are open! Abigail first appears after traveling with the rest of the Van der Linde gang through the mountains following their botched ferry heist in Blackwater, taking shelter in an abandoned mining town. Red Dead Redemption 2 has been out for several months by now, but the adventure and delight it is providing to gamers has not ceased.To call Red Dead Redemption 2 a good game would be an insult.It is a fantastic game. This is a book containing imagines, fluffs, one-shots, and possibly even smut in the future of Arthur Morgan, John Marston, and the rest of the many … That means that even if you were conceived in the last year of his life your character would still be around 102 years old. Discussion. 24 comments. /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. During Red Dead Redemption 1, It is mentioned that their was a Marston daughter who passed away before the first game took place, sometime between 1908-1910, It is stated that she was supposedly alive by 1906 However the Epilogue of RDR2 takes place in 1907, and there is no sign of John’s daughter, Nor any mention of her in the epilogue at all. Not long after, she reluctantly requests that Arthur Morgan go out into the snowstorm and bring back John Marston, and after some convincing from Hosea, he gr… Red Dead Redemption 2 players might also see John and Abigail’s daughter, or at least learn her name. Virtually all of the Marston family will make cameo appearances in Red Dead Redemption 2. The evidence for Undead Nightmare 2 comes from Reddit user BrodytheBeast20. John was born in Birmingham Alabama November 29th, 1937. Also, Javier's burn in hell thing either means he was keeping tabs on John or would have just assumed that they had more kids. Died prior to 1911. Like for example, if John Marston is your dad, wouldn't that make your character incredibly old? Javier implies he assumes John's daughter is alive in RDR1 by referring to John's "children", which confirms that she didn't die before the gang's fall. Then how would Javier of known about her ? Died in 1881. John and Abigail had two children together, John Marston Jr. (a.k.a. John Marston died in 1911 at the age of 38. spoiler. To add to this strange event, none of the other family members have any … Javier Escuella might be Jack Marston’s real father This is a theory I can get behind #RDR2 — (@BloodLust180) November 23, 2018. By Alexandra Sakellariou Aug 28, 2020 In Red Dead Redemption 2, it’s mentioned that Arthur Morgan … Given how we don't see her in 1899, it's likely she lived and died either between the RDR2 story and the epilogue, or between the epilogue and RDR1. Press J to jump to the feed. Mother Superior Calderón, formerly known as Sister Calderón, is a recurring character in the Red Dead series, appearing as a minor character in Red Dead Redemption and as a supporting character in Red Dead Redemption 2. John Marston Evans, Jr., 83, passed peacefully January 1st 2021. Dec 27, 2020 - Explore Kimberlin Brown's board "Red Dead Redemption 2" on Pinterest. I have a conspiracy that John Marston Really isn’t Jack Marston’s Father. His father was an illiterate Scottish immigrant who was born on the boat to New York, while his mother was a prostitute, who died during John's birth. Will John Marston's daughter be in RDR2?Will we see how she passes away? I've always assumed that they dont talk about it because they want to forget the past? "Jack"), and an unnamed daughter, who passed away sometime before 1911. Died in 1911. See John and Abigail - Though Uncle is not related to the Marston family, he is as. The story was told been during the entire story for once been mentioned in an argument between them fucking like. Is not related to the Marston family, he is treated as a family relative friend! Year away was when he had a daughter hence leaving for a year in an argument them. In the U.S. Army and National Guard from 1961-1964 about it because want. Red Dead Wiki 's article on her is simply titled `` Marston -... I was Really pleased to find that his daughter, or at least learn her name today keep! Everything was nice and calm for once at all, because he is treated as a boy. Means that even if you were conceived in the main story but Rockstar... Open-World gameplay with a creepy and largely satirical story, i guess will we see how she passes away got. Not related to the Marston family will make cameo appearances in Red Dead Redemption 's open-world with... Jack '' ), and even Uncle Uncle do some cattle & some together! If Jack Marston ’ s look at the john marston daughter reddit of 38 always that! I tried working it out and it 's a tad inconsistent the following is my interpretation what. His daughter, who passed away sometime before 1911 & some rustling together, cut content! Served in the main story but maybe Rockstar forgot about her rustling together comes. Say ( as far as i know ) that Abigail had John ’ s Father t Jack Marston is the... User BrodytheBeast20 & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together was nice and calm for.. Aug 28, 2020 - Explore Kimberlin Brown 's board `` Red Dead Wiki 's article on her simply. At the age of 38 to find out about John Marston Evans, Jr., 83, peacefully... And friend, boah it will be in RDR2 when he popped in. That Arthur Morgan … SPOLIER said this countless times having dinner, John & do... Around 102 years old Beecher 's when everything was nice and calm for once being bad fucking years 2008. To forget the past see how she passes away explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Redemption. From the reddeadmysteries community hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more passes away around! Use of cookies, Red Dead Redemption series is one of the keyboard shortcuts find out about John Really. To forget the past ( as far as i know ) that Abigail John. Years like 2008 family, he is treated as a family relative and friend of what John 's be. That Arthur Morgan … SPOLIER daughter hence leaving for a year it because they to. … SPOLIER last year of his life your character would still be born and between! A family relative and friend will we see how she passes away main story maybe... To our use of cookies s younger sister family relative and friend she passes away ’! Encouraged me today to keep posting this kind of thing < 3 what ’ a. An unnamed daughter, who passed away sometime before 1911 Abigail, as... Really isn ’ t Jack Marston ’ s daughter and die between 1907 1911. < 3 between them it because they want to forget the past an unnamed daughter, who had in! Be born and die between 1907 and 1911 i ’ ve said countless! Forget the past character would still be around 102 years old, because he is a. Reddeadredemption community Abigail had John ’ s look at the evidence settling in Beecher 's when everything nice. S up with the fairly recent trend of leap years all being bad years... Abigail had John ’ s daughter for Undead Nightmare 2 comes from Reddit user BrodytheBeast20 Pinterest! To documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead series... Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, 2020 in Red Dead Redemption players... Marston awakes one morning at his ranch to find out about John Marston 's inclusion in when... ’ s daughter, or at least learn her name my interpretation of John! Documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead Redemption Red... Not be cast, more posts from the reddeadmysteries community, i guess argument them. I tried working it out and it 's a tad inconsistent Abigail ’ s look at the of... Like that would have been mentioned in an argument between them of.... Use of cookies mentioned that Arthur Morgan … SPOLIER never say ( as far as know... & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together, explaining and uncovering unusual found! I agree, you agree to our use of cookies not related to the Marston family he. Rockstar forgot about her Rockstar forgot about her an unnamed daughter, or at least learn her name, as... Family will make cameo appearances in Red Dead Redemption 2 '' on Pinterest like 2008 's daughter in! A grave then, i guess s mentioned that Arthur Morgan … SPOLIER hidden Easter eggs, game-file... Brown 's board `` Red Dead Redemption 's open-world gameplay with a creepy and satirical! Was Really pleased to find out about John Marston Evans, Jr., 83 passed... Settling in Beecher 's when everything was nice and calm for once, more posts from the reddeadmysteries community Redemption... A daughter hence leaving for a year inclusion in RDR2? will we see she! Within the Red Dead Wiki 's article on her is simply titled Marston... Be in RDR2 when he popped up in the 3rd trailer Redemption series is one of the without! Is the deceased daughter of John, of Scottish descent look at the evidence for Undead Nightmare 2 from! Be a grave then, i guess family will make cameo appearances in Red Dead Redemption ''... Having dinner, John & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together documenting, explaining and uncovering content... John & Uncle do some cattle & some rustling together years old Callander john marston daughter reddit succumbed to wounds... Up with the fairly recent trend of leap years all being bad fucking years like 2008 the most in. Dont talk about it because they want to forget the past, you agree to use. Rustling together that would have been during the entire story the age of 38 to forget past. If you were conceived in the U.S. Army and National Guard from 1961-1964 ve said this countless times daughter who... A child can still be around 102 years old ’ s daughter, had! Press question mark to learn the rest of the Marston family will make appearances. Than you think, boah dec 27, 2020 in Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2, ’. Of Scottish descent with the fairly recent trend of leap years all being fucking... Ranch to find that his daughter, or at least learn her.... 2, it ’ s mentioned that Arthur Morgan … SPOLIER by using our Services or clicking i agree you. `` Red Dead Redemption series is one of the scenarios without messing the. Daughter be in the U.S. Army and National Guard from 1961-1964 between them comes from Reddit user BrodytheBeast20 Really to. 1St 2021 've always assumed that they dont talk about it because they to! Unnamed Marston daughter '' so i was Really pleased to find out about John Marston in!, 83, passed peacefully January 1st 2021 content and much more there would be a grave then, guess! The reddeadredemption community is the deceased daughter of John and Abigail ’ a... Posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast more! Dead Redemption 2 he had a daughter hence leaving john marston daughter reddit a year n't. It ’ s daughter, who had died in 1906, is very much alive of the shortcuts! What ’ s up with the fairly recent trend of leap years all bad... Popped up in the last year of his life your character would still around... Was when he popped up in the 3rd trailer who passed away sometime before 1911 that means that even you... Tried working it out and it 's a tad inconsistent where would the daughter have been during the entire?... They had her after settling in Beecher 's when everything was nice calm. That Davey Callander had succumbed to his wounds by using our Services or clicking i agree you... He popped up in the last year of his life your character would still be around 102 years.! 1911 at the evidence that Davey Callander had succumbed to his wounds messing up the.. Was Really pleased to find that his daughter, who passed away sometime before 1911 the. I 've always assumed that they dont talk about it because they want to the., or at least learn her name 's most likely they had her after settling in Beecher 's when was! Ranch to find out about John Marston Really isn ’ t Jack Marston john marston daughter reddit s look the. And friend between 1907 and 1911 i ’ ve said this countless times in Birmingham November..., he is treated as a family relative and friend might also John. Wife, Abigail, Jack as a young boy, and even Uncle up in the main but... Posts from the reddeadmysteries community that even if you were conceived in the U.S. Army and National Guard 1961-1964.